Republican candidates have it backwards on the Cuba embargo.
The Briefing
Factsheets
With Cuba, A Choice Between Forward And Backward
In
Miami, Hillary Clinton will lay out her forward-looking strategy of
engagement with Cuba, drawing a sharp comparison with Republican
candidates' efforts to continue failed Cold War policies.
Simply put, Republicans refuse to learn the lessons of the past or pay attention to what's worked and what hasn't.
Why would we continue policies that have accomplished absolutely
nothing? Fifty-four years of isolationism has strengthened the Castro
regime's grip on power, not crippled it. It's time to start empowering
the Cuban people, not the Castros.
In 2009, the US began relaxing some policies toward Cuba, and we're already witnessing the benefits.
Since then, we’ve seen a boom in Cuban entrepreneurship that validates
the power of engagement and direct exposure to American free-market
capitalism.
As President, Hillary Clinton will continue to use engagement and American leadership to build on this progress.
She will take advantage of our enhanced presence to advance our values
and interests, engage with those who support change in Cuba, address
human rights abuses, and restore our influence in the region.
So the choice is clear.
We can chart a different path forward in Cuba, betting on American
influence to lift up the Cuban people with free-market principles and
access. Or we can turn back the progress we've made in favor of failed
isolationism, and leave both our foreign policy and the Cuban people
imprisoned by the past.
Across the spectrum, people are ready for a new chapter in the relationship between the United States and Cuba:
According to Pew, 72% of Americans – and 59% of Republicans – support ending the trade embargo with Cuba.
According to Univision,
among Cuban-Americans, 40% are more likely to vote for a candidate who
supports normalization, compared to only 26% who are against it, and an overwhelming majority of Cubans in Cuba support normalization
HEADLINE: GOP House member files bill to end U.S. embargo on Cuba [USA Today, 7/28/15]
But
Republican presidential candidates continue to support the failed
policies of yesterday. Check out how their backwards rhetoric squares
with reality:
GOP Rhetoric
Reality
Marco Rubio:
“Mr. Obama’s new Cuba policy is a victory for oppressive governments
the world over and will have real, negative consequences for the
American people.”
Moving past the inflammatory rhetoric, Marco
Rubio has simply got this dead wrong. Normalizing relations with Cuba
isn’t a victory for Castro – it’s a threat. The victory for the Castro
regime has been five decades of isolationism and embargo that have
strengthened their grip of power while giving them a scapegoat for all
the island’s woes. Growing and modernizing the Cuban economy will
empower its people. And engagement with Cuba benefits Americans as well,
through increased trade and opportunities to visit family.
Jeb Bush: “We’re not a step closer to freedom in Cuba because of the actions the president’s taking.”
Starting
in 2009, the United States set out to make it easier for Cuban
Americans to visit Cuba, support private businesses, and send money to
family members. Since then, the number of annual visits by Cuban
Americans has doubled and the number of Cubans employed by small
businesses has surpassed 400,000, demonstrating the benefits and power
of engagement. And lifting the embargo fully and ensuring access to 21st
century technology would further empower the Cuban people to assert
their independence from the Castro regime.
Scott Walker:
“There’s a reason why we had the policy in the first place. I haven’t
seen solid enough evidence to make me believe there’s been a noticeable
change to change the policy this country’s had through administrations
in both parties.”
Believe it or not, Scott Walker’s assessment
of the situation is dead-on – there hasn’t been a noticeable change in
Cuba’s policy. That’s exactly the point. There was in fact “a reason we
had the policy in the first place” and the reason was because we hoped
it would cripple the Castro regime. It has not. It defies logic to
continue a policy that’s hurt the Cuban people and been at best, futile,
and at worst, counterproductive in respect to its intended goals.
Rick Perry:
“‘This is a regime that has been incredibly onerous to the people of
Cuba […] I’m not sure you’re ever going to change the culture of Cuba
until Castro is dead and gone.”
Like Walker (and the majority of
the GOP field), Perry wants to continue a policy that he admits has
failed – and in his case, he seems to concede that there is no hope for
success in the future. The isolation of Cuba has long placed burden on
the Cuban people, without anything to show for it. It’s time to lift the
embargo, take away the Castro’s excuse for its failures, and engage the
people of Cuba with American leadership.
Jeb Bush: “Obama’s rush to restore diplomatic relations with Cuba is wrong.”
Rush?
We’ve been pursuing the same failed strategy of isolationism toward
Cuba for fifty-four years. It’s high time to acknowledge that it hasn’t
worked, and move forwar
Presidential
candidates Hillary Clinton, former Governor Jeb Bush (R-FL), Dr. Ben
Carson, former Governor Martin O’Malley (D-MD), and Senator Bernie
Sanders (I-VT) spoke at the National Urban League conference in Fort
Lauderdale, Florida.
Hillary Clinton: “Race still plays a significant role in determining who gets ahead in America and who gets left behind.”
Good
morning. Good morning. Wow. This is a great way to start my day. And
I’m delighted to be here with you. I want to thank Marc for not only the
introduction, but all of his work over the years. I have been a fan of
Marc’s since he was mayor of New Orleans. He did great work there — and
he’s doing great work at the National Urban League. So thank you, Marc.
And we’re all thinking, as I hope we do every year, about New Orleans as
we near the 10th anniversary of Katrina. Something like that should
never be allowed to happen in the United States of America again. So we
have to keep learning the lessons and re-pledging our commitment.
I
want to thank everyone for welcoming me here today. I want to give a
shout-out to your national chairman of the board Michael Neidorff; also,
backstage I saw a longtime friend of mine, Congressman Alcee Hastings;
and Alexis Herman, who served in my husband’s administration; and Tony
West, who served in President Obama’s administration. There’s a
veritable hall of fame here for this event. And I can never come to a
National Urban League gathering without mentioning my lifelong friend
Vernon Jordan. He may not be here today, but he’s with us in spirit
because of his deep love and commitment to this organization.
It’s
also close to my heart. Over the years, I’ve gotten the chance to work
with you, learn from you. I’ve pored over your State of Black America
reports, I’ve spoken at your conferences, but most importantly, I’ve
seen how you change people’s lives.
The
theme of this conference — “Saving Our Cities: Education, Jobs and
Justice” — speaks to the important work that you’ve been doing for
decades. I know that you help black entrepreneurs get start-up capital. I
know you help people find jobs. I know you give families financial
counseling so they can achieve their dreams of buying a home or sending
their kids to college. And you make sure parents have the tools to take
care of their kids’ health. That’s the kind of day-to-day commitment
that makes such a difference. As you help prepare young people for
college and work in a world that can sometimes make them feel that
they’re not very important, you make sure they know just how precious
and powerful they really are.
This
vital work has been my work too. My first job out of law school wasn’t
at some big law firm; it was with the Children’s Defense Fund, started
by Marian Wright Edelman. That first summer after I graduated, I went
door to door for kids shut out of school and denied the education they
deserve. I also began a lifelong concern by working with the CDF to try
to figure out what we did with kids caught up in the juvenile and adult
prison systems. As First Lady, I helped create the Children’s Health
Insurance Program. You were an ally in doing that. As Senator, I
championed small businesses owned by women and people of color, because
that’s where a lot of the jobs in America come from. I fought to raise
the minimum wage — because no one who works hard in America should have
to raise their kids in poverty.
These
issues — your issues — are deeply personal to me. So I’m here early on
this morning, first and foremost, to say thank you. But I’m also here to
talk about the future — because the work you have been doing is more
important than ever, and I’m going to keep doing that work right
alongside you.
Now, I would
love nothing more than to stay and have a conversation for hours, going
into depth about every single issue that we are worried about, but you
have a full slate of speakers that will follow me. So let me make three
points about the work we need to do together.
First:
The opportunity gap that America is facing is not just about economic
inequality. It is about racial inequality. Now, that may seem obvious to
you, but it bears underscoring because some of the evidence that backs
it up would come as a shock to many Americans. Like how African
Americans are nearly three times as likely as whites to be denied a
mortgage. Or how, in 2013, the median wealth for white families was more
than $134,000 — but for African American families, it was just $11,000.
A
lot of people don’t realize that our schools are more segregated today
than they were in 1968. Or even that African Americans are sentenced to
longer prison terms than white people for the same crimes. Or that
political operatives are trying every trick in the book to prevent
African Americans from voting.
And
listen to this one, because as somebody who started with the Children’s
Defense Fund and who now is the proud and delighted grandmother of a
10-month-old granddaughter — African American children are 500
percent — 500 percent — more likely to die from asthma than white kids.
Now, I studied and advocated and introduced legislation to close health
disparities. I knew how severe they were, but 500 percent?
So
all of this points to an unavoidable conclusion: race. Race still plays
a significant role in determining who gets ahead in America and who
gets left behind. And yes, while that’s partly a legacy of
discrimination that stretches back to the start of our nation, it is
also because of discrimination that is still ongoing.
I’m
not saying anything you don’t already know. You understand this better
than I do — better than anyone. But I want to say it anyway. Because I’m
planning to be President, and anyone who seeks that office has a
responsibility to say it. And more than that, to grapple with the
systemic inequities that so many Americans face. Anyone who asks for
your vote should try their hardest to see things as they actually are,
not just as we want them to be. So I want you to know I see it and I
hear you. And the racial disparity you work hard every day to overcome
go against everything I believe in, and everything I want to help
America achieve.
The second
point is this: This is not just about statistics, as damning as they can
be. This is about Americans doing some soul-searching and holding
ourselves to account. This is about all of us looking into our hearts,
examining our assumptions and fears, and asking ourselves: What more can
I do in my life to counter hate and injustice? How can I make our
country a better, fairer place?
Let
me be clear: I think all of us need to do that kind of introspection.
But those of us who have not experienced systemic racial inequities — we
have an extra obligation. We need to do a better job of listening when
people talk about the seen and unseen barriers they face every day. We
need to practice humility, rather than assume that our experiences are
everyone’s experiences. And yes, we need to try, as best we can, to walk
in one another’s shoes — to imagine what it would be like to sit our
son down and have “the talk,” or if people followed us around stores, or
locked their car doors when we walked past.
That
empathy — that’s what makes it possible for people from every
background, every race, every religion, to come together as one nation.
That’s the kind of generosity of spirit that makes a country like
America endure. And given what we’ve seen and experienced over the last
two years, this is an urgent call for people to search their own hearts
and minds.
Here’s my third
point: We’ve arrived at a moment when all these challenges are in sharp
relief, and we have to seize it. Too many times now, Americans have come
together, in shock and horror, to process a violent, senseless tragedy.
Like Trayvon Martin, shot to death not in some empty, desolate street
somewhere, but in a gated community. He wasn’t a stranger, he had family
there. Or Sandra Bland, a college-educated young woman who knew her
rights, who didn’t do anything wrong, but still ended up dying in a jail
cell. Together, we’ve mourned Tamir Rice and Eric Garner, Walter Scott
and Freddie Gray, and most recently, Sam Dubose. These names are
emblazoned on our hearts. We’ve seen their faces, we’ve heard their
grieving families. We’ve seen a massacre in Charleston, and black
churches set on fire — today, in 2015.
But
thankfully, tragedy is not all we have seen. Yes, the Confederate
battle flag came down finally in South Carolina. The families of the
Charleston victims reached out with extraordinary grace to the man who
killed their loved ones. And President Obama delivered a eulogy that
sounded as though it had come straight from angels, ending with Amazing
Grace. Young people have taken to the streets, dignified and determined,
urging us to affirm the basic fact that black lives matter. And because
of people across this country sharing their stories with courage and
strength, a growing number of Americans are realizing what many of you
have been saying for a long time — we can’t go on like this; we are
better than this; things must change.
Now,
it’s up to us to build on that momentum, and we all have to do our
part — but those of us who strive to lead have a special responsibility.
I’m
very pleased that many presidential candidates will be here today to
address you. It is a signal that the work you’ve been doing — laboring
in the vineyards for decades — is getting the political attention it
deserves. But the real test of a candidate’s commitment is not whether
we come to speak at your national conference, as important as that is.
It’s whether we’re still around after the cameras are gone and the votes
are counted. It’s whether our positions live up to our rhetoric.
And
too often we see a mismatch between what some candidates say in venues
like this, and what they actually do when they’re elected. I don’t think
you can credibly say that everyone has a “right to rise” and then say
you’re for phasing out Medicare or for repealing Obamacare. People can’t
rise if they can’t afford health care. They can’t rise if the minimum
wage is too low to live on. They can’t rise if their governor makes it
harder for them to get a college education. And you cannot seriously
talk about the right to rise and support laws that deny the right to
vote.
So yes, what people
say matters, but what they do matters more. Americans, especially today,
deserve leaders who will face inequity, race and justice issues in all
their complexity head on — who won’t just concede that there are
barriers holding people back, who will do instead what it takes to tear
those barriers down, once and for all.
I
will never stop working on issues of equality and opportunity, race and
justice. That is a promise. I’ve done it my entire adult life. I will
always be in your corner. Because issues like these — they are why I’m
running for president. They are why I got involved in public service in
the first place — to tear down the barriers that hold people back from
developing their talents and achieving their dreams.
I’m
asking you to hold me accountable, to hold all of us accountable.
Because the work that you’re doing must lead to action. And you deserve
leaders who not only get that, but who will work hard every day to make
our country a better place — to make it live up to its potential and to
provide the opportunities for every single child in this country to live
up to his or her God-given potential.
Yes,
I do have this 10-month-old grandchild now, and I’ve got to tell
you — those of you who already have reached this incredible,
transformational point in your lives understand this — there is nothing
like it to focus you on the present. When Bill and I are with Charlotte,
doing our best to babysit — the phones are off, the TV is off; we’re
just focused on this miracle of life. And we’re the kind of
grandparents, I’ll confess, that when she learns to clap her hands we
give her a standing ovation. But you see, it’s not just about our
granddaughter, is it? We, of course, will do everything we can to make
sure she has all the opportunities she should — as a citizen of this
country, as a child of God, as a person who has the right to go as far
as her hard work and talent will take her. But that’s not enough. I
don’t want that just for my granddaughter. I’m the granddaughter of a
factory worker who worked from the time he was a teenager to the time he
retired in the Scranton lace mills. I know how blessed I’ve been, and
opportunities that I had that others with just as much talent did not.
So
let us tear down the barriers so no matter whose child you are or
grandchild you are, you too will have the same chance. I’m proud to be
your ally. I’m committed to being your partner. I will keep fightingright
alongside you, today and always, to make the United States of America a
country where all men and women, all boys and girls, are treated as
they deserve to be — as equals. I know we can do this. I know the path
ahead is not easy. But I’m absolutely convinced that we will once again
join hands and make a difference for those young people who not only
need a path, but need the love and embrace of a grateful nation for the
contributions they each will make to a better future for us all.
Here is a response, an important one, that you can use to counter those who keep insisting that Hillary has a "trustworthiness" problem. From The Briefing. Here is a little peek.
Hillary
Clinton traveled to Ft. Lauderdale and Miami where she spoke at the
National Urban League and delivered remarks on the need to end the
embargo on Cuba.
Here’s what people are saying:
2015 National Urban League Conference
14. BuzzFeed: Hillary Wins The Only Standing Ovation From An Obama Crowd Clinton
was undoubtedly the candidate folks at the annual convention had wanted
to see most. She got the loudest welcoming applause, the most people
clamoring for a brief audience with her, and the most widespread
approval by members of the Urban League, who gave her speech the
morning's only standing ovation. Read more >>>>
